Italy's data protection authority Garante has fined Meta €805 million over a Facebook for Android feature that suggests photos and videos from users' phone galleries for posting. The regulator determined that the feature was enabled by default and accessed Italian users' photos, videos, and related metadata without obtaining explicit consent.
The authority found that the app requests gallery access through a single permission covering multiple functions with different purposes. A general notice about enabling other features appears first but fails to clearly inform users that they are also granting access for gallery suggestions. Once granted, this permission allows the app to read the entire photo archive on an ongoing basis, with no mechanism for users or the authority to verify which data is actually used.
The ruling cites a breach of Article 122 of Italy's Privacy Code, which incorporates the EU's ePrivacy Directive into national law. This provision treats a phone as part of a person's private life, requiring free and informed consent for any access to stored data regardless of whether information is transmitted elsewhere or harm occurs.
Garante has ordered Meta to take several actions within strict timelines:
- Within 60 days, request consent through a separate, specific prompt that explains the feature's purpose, its access to the gallery, and how to disable it.
- Within 60 days, keep the feature disabled by default, including for users who have already granted gallery permission.
- Within 30 days, report initial compliance steps to the authority, followed by a full report within 90 days.
If the deadlines are missed, the feature cannot be activated for any user who has not provided valid consent. Meta stated that the feature only operates after device permission is granted and can be changed at any time, and it plans to appeal the fine as disproportionate. The Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti consumer group, whose complaint triggered the investigation, has advised users to disable gallery suggestion settings and review app permissions.


